NVM vs Mise: Choosing the Right Node.js Version Manager

Node.js version management has evolved significantly since nvm's introduction. While nvm remains the most widely adopted solution for switching between Node.js versions, newer tools like Mise challenge its dominance by addressing performance bottlenecks and expanding beyond single-language management.

This comparison examines both tools' strengths, limitations, and ideal use cases to help you select the version manager that fits your workflow.

What is NVM?

NVM (Node Version Manager) provides a simple approach to installing and switching between Node.js versions. Nvm has since become the de facto standard for Node.js version management, particularly among developers working exclusively with JavaScript.

The tool operates by modifying your shell's PATH variable to point to different Node.js installations stored in ~/.nvm/versions/node/. This straightforward approach works reliably across Unix-based systems, though Windows users require alternatives like nvm-windows.

NVM focuses exclusively on Node.js. If you work with Ruby, Python, or other languages, you'll need separate version managers for each, creating potential conflicts and shell startup overhead.

What is Mise?

Mise (formerly rtx) represents a newer generation of version management tools. Built in Rust rather than shell scripts, Mise manages multiple programming languages through a single unified interface while adding environment variable management and task running capabilities.

Originally created as an asdf alternative, Mise maintains backward compatibility with existing version files from nvm, rbenv, pyenv, and asdf. This compatibility strategy reduces migration friction while delivering performance improvements through its compiled architecture.

Mise extends beyond version switching. The tool handles project-specific environment variables through .mise.toml configuration files and includes a task runner that can replace Makefiles or package.json scripts. This consolidation reduces the number of tools competing for shell integration.

Quick Comparison

Installation and setup

NVM installation requires downloading and executing a bash script:

curl -o- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nvm-sh/nvm/v0.39.0/install.sh | bash

The script modifies your .bashrc, .zshrc, or equivalent shell configuration file to load nvm on startup. You'll need to restart your terminal or source the configuration before using nvm.

Mise offers multiple installation methods. The quickest uses the official installer:

curl https://mise.run | sh

You can also install via package managers like Homebrew, apt, or Cargo. After installation, add shell activation to your configuration:

echo 'eval "$(mise activate bash)"' >> ~/.bashrc

Both tools require shell integration, but Mise's activation typically completes faster due to its compiled nature.

Managing Node.js versions

NVM provides straightforward commands for Node.js version management:

# List available versions
nvm ls-remote

# Install a version
nvm install 22.0.0

# Use a version
nvm use 22.0.0

# Set default version
nvm alias default 22.0.0

Version switching with nvm affects only your current shell session unless you set a default. Opening a new terminal window reverts to the default version rather than project-specific versions.

Mise handles versions similarly but with consistent syntax across all supported languages:

# List available versions
mise ls-remote node

# Install a version
mise install node@22.0.0

# Set global version
mise use --global node@22

# Set project version
mise use node@22

The key difference: Mise automatically switches versions when you navigate to directories containing .mise.toml or .node-version files. This automatic switching eliminates the manual nvm use commands you'd run with nvm.

Project-specific configurations

NVM supports .nvmrc files for specifying project Node.js versions:

echo "22.0.0" > .nvmrc

However, nvm doesn't automatically switch versions when entering directories. You must either run nvm use manually or add shell hooks that call nvm use on directory changes. Many developers rely on third-party solutions like zsh-nvm for automatic switching.

Mise implements automatic version switching natively. Creating a .mise.toml file in your project:

[tools]
node = "22.0.0"

Mise detects this configuration and switches Node.js versions automatically as you navigate your filesystem. This works without additional plugins or shell functions.

Mise also reads .nvmrc files directly, so existing nvm projects work immediately without converting configuration files.

Beyond Node.js

NVM exclusively manages Node.js. If your projects use Ruby, Python, Go, or other languages, you'll install separate version managers:

• rbenv or RVM for Ruby
• pyenv for Python
  
• gvm for Go
• tfenv for Terraform

Each tool adds its own shell initialization overhead and uses different command syntax. Managing versions across multiple languages means learning distinct tools and maintaining separate configurations.

Mise manages all these languages through consistent commands:

mise install ruby@3.3.0
mise install python@3.12.0
mise install go@1.21.0

A single .mise.toml file specifies all project tools:

[tools]
node = "22.0.0"
ruby = "3.3.0"
python = "3.12.0"

This unified approach reduces cognitive load and shell startup time compared to running multiple version managers simultaneously.

Environment variable management

NVM doesn't handle environment variables. You'll typically use separate tools like direnv or dotenv alongside nvm for project-specific environment configuration.

Mise integrates environment variable management directly into .mise.toml:

[tools]
node = "22.0.0"

[env]
DATABASE_URL = "postgresql://localhost/myapp"
API_KEY = "dev-key-123"
NODE_ENV = "development"

These variables become available automatically when entering the project directory and disappear when leaving. This scoping prevents environment pollution between projects without requiring additional tools.

Task running

NVM provides no task running capabilities. Developers typically use npm scripts, Makefiles, or tools like just for task automation.

Mise includes built-in task running:

[tasks.test]
run = "npm test"
description = "Run tests"

[tasks.dev]
run = "npm run dev"
description = "Start dev server"

Run tasks with mise run test or mise run dev. Tasks execute in the context of configured tools and environment variables, ensuring consistency across team members.

This feature particularly benefits projects that need pre-configured environments before running commands. Rather than documenting "set these environment variables then run this command," the task encapsulates everything.

Compatibility and migration

NVM works exclusively with Node.js projects. If you're switching from nvm to another Node.js version manager, you'll need to reinstall Node.js versions and potentially adjust shell configurations.

Mise prioritizes backward compatibility. The tool reads: - .nvmrc files from nvm - .node-version files from nodenv - .tool-versions files from asdf - .ruby-version, .python-version, and other language-specific files

This compatibility means Mise works with existing projects immediately. You don't need to convert configuration files or convince your entire team to switch simultaneously. Team members can continue using nvm while you use Mise with the same project.

Community and ecosystem

NVM benefits from over a decade of development and widespread adoption. The tool has 80,000+ GitHub stars and extensive documentation. Most Node.js tutorials mention nvm, and you'll find solutions to common problems readily available.

The main nvm repository includes numerous issues related to performance and shell integration complexity. Many longstanding issues remain unresolved due to fundamental limitations in the bash-based architecture.

Mise has a smaller but growing community. Created in 2022, the tool has gained traction among developers frustrated with traditional version managers' performance. The project maintains active development with frequent releases addressing user feedback.

Mise documentation covers basic usage comprehensively, though advanced scenarios sometimes require consulting GitHub issues. The smaller ecosystem means fewer third-party integrations compared to nvm.

Final thoughts

Neither tool is clearly better than the other. It depends on your needs and setup. If you mostly work with JavaScript and do not need support for other languages, NVM is the safer choice. It is widely used, stable, and supported by a strong community.

If you work with multiple languages and want a single tool to manage them, Mise may be a better fit. It makes switching versions easier and reduces the hassle of juggling different managers.

In short, choose NVM if your work is mainly JavaScript, but choose Mise if you often switch between languages like Python, Ruby, and Node.js

Got an article suggestion? Let us know

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.