What Are the Main Differences Between Graylog2 and Kibana

Graylog and Kibana are both popular tools used for log management and data analysis in combination with centralized log collection systems like Elasticsearch. However, they differ significantly in their features, use cases, and focus. Below is a comparison of the main differences between Graylog2 (often referred to simply as Graylog) and Kibana:

1. Primary Functionality

• Graylog:
  • A complete log management solution that focuses on log collection, parsing, and analysis.
  • Provides an end-to-end solution for collecting logs from various sources, processing and normalizing them, and then storing them in Elasticsearch or MongoDB.
  • Features a built-in alerting system, log filtering, and correlation features.
• Kibana:
  • A data visualization and exploration tool primarily used with Elasticsearch.
  • Does not manage or collect logs itself but works on top of Elasticsearch for visualizing data, building dashboards, and analyzing log information.
  • Often paired with tools like Logstash or Beats for log collection.

2. Log Ingestion and Processing

• Graylog:
  • Has its own log ingestion and processing pipelines with built-in support for Grok patterns, extractors, and pipelines for parsing and structuring data.
  • You can apply rules to enrich, transform, or discard log data before it is indexed in Elasticsearch.
  • Graylog Inputs: Allows multiple input types (e.g., Syslog, GELF, HTTP, Beats) and manages ingestion in a unified platform.
• Kibana:
  • Does not handle log ingestion directly. It relies on Elasticsearch for storage and index management and on external tools like Logstash, Beats, or custom pipelines to ingest and process data.
  • No built-in log parsing or normalization; all data structuring must happen before reaching Elasticsearch.

3. Alerting and Notifications

• Graylog:
  • Has native alerting capabilities that allow you to set up thresholds and conditions on logs and receive alerts via email, Slack, or HTTP.
  • You can define conditions like specific error codes, rate limits, or message content, and trigger notifications when these are met.
• Kibana:
  • Alerting is provided through the Elasticsearch Stack (formerly X-Pack) or through plugins.
  • Kibana's alerting features are more advanced but require an Elastic Stack license (basic features are free, but some advanced alerting comes under a paid subscription).
  • Kibana also supports watchers in Elasticsearch to create alerts, which can be more complex but highly customizable.

4. Data Visualization

• Graylog:
  • Provides basic visualization options for logs like charts, tables, and histograms, but it is not as advanced or flexible as Kibana’s visualizations.
  • More focused on log management than advanced data exploration.
• Kibana:
  • Advanced visualization tool with rich capabilities for creating interactive dashboards, graphs, and charts.
  • Allows users to create complex dashboards, drill down into data, and use custom visualizations, making it excellent for analyzing trends and patterns in log data.
  • Supports Timelion, Vega, and Canvas for building highly customized visualizations.

5. User Interface and Usability

• Graylog:
  • Offers an interface tailored for log management and security use cases. It has a clean, intuitive UI that is focused on log search, alerting, and processing.
  • Designed for engineers, system administrators, and security professionals looking for centralized log management and analysis.
• Kibana:
  • The UI is centered around data visualization and exploration. It’s more flexible for general data analysis and building complex dashboards but may have a steeper learning curve if used for pure log management.
  • Great for analysts, data scientists, and business users who want more powerful visualization options.

6. Log Searching and Filtering

• Graylog:
  • Designed for log-centric search, it provides full-text search, time-based searches, and log correlation.
  • It has built-in support for streaming logs in real time and filtering them into different streams.
  • Allows for fine-grained log filtering and enrichment at the time of ingestion using extractors and pipelines.
• Kibana:
  • Elasticsearch Query DSL and Lucene-based search: Offers powerful, detailed search capabilities, but you need to be familiar with Elasticsearch’s query language for advanced filtering.
  • Kibana’s interface is designed more for visual exploration of data than direct log filtering, though Discover in Kibana allows for basic log search and filtering.

7. Architecture and Integration

• Graylog:
  • A complete log management solution built on top of Elasticsearch and MongoDB.
  • Provides all the necessary components for log ingestion, processing, searching, alerting, and visualization within one platform.
  • Easy to set up for centralized logging without needing additional tools like Logstash or Beats.
• Kibana:
  • Part of the Elastic Stack, but does not manage logs directly. It depends on Logstash, Beats, or custom pipelines for log collection and enrichment.
  • Fully integrated with Elasticsearch but requires additional setup for log ingestion.

8. Ease of Setup and Use

• Graylog:
  • Easier to set up as a standalone log management system because it integrates everything in one platform (ingestion, search, processing, alerting).
  • Ideal for users who want a single tool for all logging needs.
• Kibana:
  • Needs a more modular setup. You have to configure Elasticsearch, and use Logstash, Beats, or other tools for data ingestion.
  • More flexible for general data analysis, but requires multiple components to achieve full log management functionality.

9. Licensing and Costs

• Graylog:
  • Graylog Open Source is free and includes most essential features for log management.
  • There is a Graylog Enterprise version that offers additional features like archiving, event correlation, and advanced security features, available under a paid subscription.
• Kibana:
  • Kibana is open-source, but advanced features such as alerting, security, machine learning, and certain visualization tools require a paid Elastic Stack license (basic and premium tiers).

10. Use Cases

• Graylog:
  • Primarily used for log management, security event monitoring, and system auditing.
  • Ideal for IT operations, security teams (SIEM), and DevOps who need an integrated log management solution with alerting and centralized log storage.
• Kibana:
  • Ideal for data exploration, business analytics, and general data visualization.
  • Used in a wide variety of use cases, from web analytics to performance monitoring and security analytics, when paired with Elasticsearch as the data store.

Summary

Conclusion:

• Graylog is more suited for centralized log management with alerting and monitoring features.
• Kibana excels in data visualization and exploration when working with large datasets in Elasticsearch, but relies on external tools for log ingestion.

If you’re looking for a log management solution, Graylog is the better choice. For data visualization and analysis of a broader range of data, Kibana is more powerful.

Got an article suggestion? Let us know

Explore more

Graylog Kibana Logstash

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.