Why There Are Two Ways to Unstage a File in Git?

In Git, there are indeed two primary commands to unstage a file: git reset and git restore. Each serves a specific purpose and fits different workflows and stages of development. Let's explore the reasons for having these two commands and when to use each.

1. git reset

git reset is a versatile command used for various purposes, including unstaging files, moving branch pointers, and more. When used to unstage a file, it changes the state of the index (staging area) without altering the working directory.

Unstaging with git reset:

git reset HEAD <file>

• HEAD refers to the latest commit on the current branch.
• This command resets the index entry for <file> to the state it was in the last commit, effectively unstaging it.

Why git reset?

• Historical Usage: git reset has been part of Git for a long time and was one of the initial ways to manipulate the staging area.
• Powerful and Flexible: git reset can be used for more than just unstaging. It can also move the current branch to a different commit (-hard, -soft, -mixed options), making it a powerful tool for rewriting history.
• Consistency: Users familiar with the more advanced capabilities of git reset find it consistent to use it for unstaging as well.

2. git restore

git restore is a relatively newer command introduced to simplify and clarify some common Git operations. It was designed to be more intuitive and focused on specific tasks like restoring files in the working directory and the index.

Unstaging with git restore:

git restore --staged <file>

• -staged tells Git to operate on the staging area, effectively unstaging <file>.

Why git restore?

• Clarity and Simplicity: git restore makes it clear that the operation is related to restoring the state of files, either in the working directory or the staging area. This helps beginners understand what the command does without overloading them with the broader functionalities of git reset.
• Task-Specific Commands: Git has been evolving to provide more task-specific commands (git switch, git restore) to improve usability and reduce the complexity for new users. This aligns with a more modern approach to tool design, where commands do one thing well.
• Clear Intent: Using git restore --staged explicitly communicates that the operation is about unstaging, making scripts and commands more readable and intention-revealing.

When to Use Each Command

• Use git reset if:
  • You are comfortable with its broader functionality and prefer to use a single command for various index and commit manipulations.
  • You need to perform more advanced operations, such as moving branch pointers or resetting to a specific commit.
• Use git restore if:
  • You prefer a clearer and more intuitive command for unstaging files.
  • You are newer to Git or prefer to use commands that are more specific to the task at hand.

Example Scenario

Suppose you have staged a file example.txt but realize you need to unstage it.

Using git reset:

git reset HEAD example.txt

This resets example.txt in the index to match the HEAD commit, effectively unstaging it.

Using git restore:

git restore --staged example.txt

This unstages example.txt with a command that clearly indicates its purpose.

Conclusion

Having both git reset and git restore provides flexibility and clarity, catering to both advanced users and beginners. While git reset offers powerful and flexible capabilities, git restore provides a more intuitive and focused approach for specific tasks like unstaging files.

Got an article suggestion? Let us know

Explore more

Git

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.